Page 1 of 1

Buildings for Blea Moor

Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2017 5:02 pm
by martink
An initial experiment - a first attempt at the main Ribblehead station building. A 3d printed shell with roof detail and indentations for the doors and windows, painted, then with door and window detail printed on paper and glued in.

The usual cruel, cruel closeups, but the technique seems to work well enough that I expect to do all the buildings this way.
rh-stcad1.jpg
rh-stcad1.jpg (47.26 KiB) Viewed 5072 times
DSCI0052.JPG
DSCI0052.JPG (131.27 KiB) Viewed 5072 times
DSCI0051.JPG
DSCI0051.JPG (177.14 KiB) Viewed 5072 times

Re: Buildings for Blea Moor

Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2017 10:38 pm
by msimister
Looks pretty good Martin and looking forward to seeing the whole layout.

One question, not just for you: I appreciate the things that can be done with 3D printing (all my rolling stock is 3D printed and the large number of buildings on Doug's Bridge layout make it the only really practical way in a relatively short space of time) but do you get the satisfaction from it that comes with handcrafting a model? I've only made two buildings for T gauge so far, both made in more traditional modelling ways adapted for the even smaller scale, and both have given me a lot of satisfaction, at least partly because of the challenge of making them in T scale. So, my question really comes down to, is the satisfaction in having the model or in building it? What think you and others?

Cheers,
Malcolm

Re: Buildings for Blea Moor

Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2017 2:00 am
by martink
msimister wrote:... is the satisfaction in having the model or in building it? What think you and others?
Hmm, that isn't really an either/or question. Both reasons (and more!) apply:
- the satisfaction of taking an idea and turning it into a tangible, physical, working object (the main one, it applies at all stages, from the component level to and whole layout)
- watching others seeing the layout the first time (expressions of surprise on peoples' faces seeing T for the first time)
- 3d permits us to build things that would not be practicable using conventional techniques (some models would have been, but not with the same quantity, detail, and/or complexity)
- the very limited range of RTR in T (it would not be a viable modelling scale without 3d)
- etc.

Re: Buildings for Blea Moor

Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2017 10:17 am
by dkightley
Sorry we've highjacked the subject of the thread.....
... is the satisfaction in having the model or in building it? What think you and others?
For me, the satisfaction is on several levels...

Firstly, the achievement of finishing something you set out to achieve.

Then there's the satisfaction of producing each individual part...the CAD work, the printing, the painting...and then the setting into place on the layout. 3D printing is not a "shortcut" to get a finished component in the shortest possible time....it has its challenges. And its not only 3D printing....I'm referring to traditional crafts as well.

And for me, the greatest satisfaction is seeing the pleasure all my hard work brings to others. I've stood behind The Bridge for more than twenty five exhibition days....and I've seen the hundreds of looks of amazement, awe, and pleasure that the layout has created. That's satisfaction that words can't describe!